Killing an Ant with a Sledge Hammer

Omoyele Sowore, former Presidential candidate of the African Motion Congress (AAC) and writer of the net citizen newspaper, Sahara Reporters, has been dominating the information because the Division of State Providers picked him up in a Lagos lodge on Saturday August 3, 2019 for calling out Nigerians for a mass protest on August 5 2019 in opposition to the federal government below the hashtag #RevolutionNow. He was accused of committing treasonable felony by attempting to make use of violent means to overthrow the Buhari authorities. On Tuesday August 6, 2019, the DSS introduced an software earlier than Justice Taiwo Taiwo of the Abuja division of the excessive court docket, (who’s sitting as a trip Choose), and stated it could have to hold Sowere in custody past the statutorily allowed 48 hours after arrest until all its investigations have been concluded.

One of many points round Sowore’s name for a revolution was that there was a video clip of him the place he threatened that after the protest each the federal government and the DSS would stop to exist. I’ll haven’t any drawback with DSS inviting Sowere to clarify what he meant by these statements or what his #RevolutionNow was meant to realize. Most accountable governments would accomplish that, particularly if such threats come from public figures. As a candidate within the February 23 2019 presidential election and a writer, Sowere, can’t be referred to as an innocuous persona. Many Nigerians nonetheless see extra to Sowere’s arrest than the official allegation of attempting to overthrow the federal government utilizing revolutionary means.

There are at the very least three contending views on why Sowere deliberate the mass protest, and why the federal government picked him up:

The primary is that Sowore, who contested within the final presidential election and scored 33,953 votes, wished to place himself because the voice and face of the opposition and subsequently intentionally courted arrest not simply by utilizing a #RevolutionNow hasttag but additionally by allegedly threatening that each the federal government and the DSS would stop to exist. In truth, since his detention, Sowore has dominated each native and worldwide information about Nigeria, with teams and people against the federal government coalescing to showcase his detention as one other occasion of the federal government’s intolerance and even descent to the darkish days of Abacha’s brutal dictatorship. If this conspiracy principle is true, then the federal government solely performed into Sowere’s arms.

The second perspective in Sowere’s #RevolutionNow protest is that Sowore is definitely enjoying out the federal government’s script. It must be recalled that Sowore unreservedly supported Buhari throughout the 2015 election. In accordance with this angle, the federal government, rattled by a number of the revelations on the Election Petition Tribunal (the place the result of the final presidential election is being challenged), has turn out to be more and more jittery a couple of potential unfavourable judgment and subsequently needs to create an Orwellian state of affairs by creating an impression of both an impending revolution or navy takeover as a justification to both clamp down on dissent and even declare a State of Emergency.

The third perspective is that Sowore and Rotimi Amaechi, the previous Minister of Transport and former Governor of Rivers State, had a deal throughout the simply concluded governorship election in Rivers, which went bitter. It must be recalled that after the courts disqualified the APC from fielding candidates within the elections in Rivers and Zamfara States (aside from the presidential elections), Rotimi Amaechi adopted the African Motion Congress (AAC), Sowore’s celebration, as his most well-liked political celebration, and sponsored its gubernatorial candidate Awara Biokpomabo throughout the election- in what was clearly a continuation of his battle with Nyesom Wike for the management of the state. Nyesom Wike received however AAC, which barely had buildings anyplace within the nation put up a surprisingly spectacular efficiency, polling 173,859 votes to complete runner as much as Nyesom Wike who polled 886,264 votes. Sowere, because the celebration’s presidential candidate, managed to ballot solely 33,953 votes nationwide. Some conspiracy theorists have claimed that Sowere was promised both financial compensation or a ministerial appointment for making his celebration out there to Amaechi in Rvers, and selected to battle again with the decision for a revolution, when the guarantees made to him weren’t redeemed. Individuals who subscribe to this ‘theory’ typically level out that Nyesom Wike was the primary governor to declare that the #RevolutionNow protest wouldn’t be allowed to happen in Rivers State.

ALSO READ:  Actress Ruth Kadiri And Her Husband Expecting Their First Baby

The above are in fact all conspiracy theories, and as with all conspiracy theories, there’ll all the time be parts that appear to validate every principle and a number of others that can problem it. For this, we are going to by no means actually know the reality particularly because the variety of conspiracy theories is prone to rise because the Sowore debacle continues to unfold.

A related query right here is whether or not Sowore’s name for a revolution was sufficient for the DSS to select him up on grounds of treasonable felony and to subsequently strategy a court docket for an order to carry him for as much as 90 days (assuming that Sowore was not enjoying a authorities’s script, as some argue)? Whereas I would not have any drawback with the DSS inviting Sowere for interrogation (and even selecting him up as they did to clarify what he hoped to realize along with his deliberate protest), I consider that it will likely be counterproductive for the federal government to attempt to maintain him in detention for as much as 90 days as demanded by the DSS.

Even when Sowore referred to as for a revolution and proclaimed that each the DSS and the federal government would stop to exist, does he actually have the capability to effectuate his menace? In America’s free speech jurisprudence, ‘clear and present danger’ take a look at is commonly used to find out the circumstances below which limits could be positioned on the nation’s First Modification’s ensures of freedoms of speech, press and meeting. This take a look at was developed in a landmark case in 1919 (Schenck v. United States) by Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes, Jr. who argued thus:

“The question in every case is whether the words used are used in such circumstances and are of such a nature as to create a clear and present danger that they will bring about the substantive evils that the United States Congress has a right to prevent. It is a question of proximity and degree.” Since Schenck v. United States, “clear and present danger” grew to become each a public metaphor for First Modification speech and a normal take a look at in instances earlier than the Court docket the place a United States legislation limits a citizen’s First Modification rights. A lot of the main democracies have related exams on when a menace could be stated to have turn out to be potent sufficient to warrant the abridgment of residents’ freedoms of speech, affiliation and meeting. On this context some essential questions are: what number of battalions of troopers has Sowore secretly constructed as much as assist him overrun Nigerian military and safety companies to effectuate his revolution? The reply is most probably Nil. Does Sowere have the type of subtle group wanted to mobilize residents for a revolution throughout the nation (particularly given the depth of our fault traces), and to maintain the mobilized residents for a chronic interval of anti-government protest? The reply is most probably No. If the reply to every of those questions is a powerful ‘No’, then the federal government could also be attempting to kill an ant with a sledge hammer.

ALSO READ:  Busted! How A Director Allegedly Stole N30m HIV/AIDS Funds In Akwa Ibom

Since this can be very uncertain that Sowere has the capability to pose a menace to the Nigerian state – even when he needs to – my concern is {that a} mishandling of the Sowere affair, could result in the creation of one other enormous monster which will pose an actual menace to the federal government. There are indicators that the federal government could already be doing this by allegedly placing Amnesty Worldwide on safety surveillance for re-tweeting the hashtag, #RevolutionNow. What precisely does the federal government hope to realize by that? Sadly if the purpose was to intimidate or frighten them, it might find yourself attaining the alternative impact as a result of it might result in the assorted transnational NGOs and civil rights teams uniting in opposition to the federal government.

There’s additionally the query of whether or not revolution essentially means a violent change of presidency (as the federal government interpreted the phrase) – assuming that Sowere has the capability to hold out a revolution in Nigeria. The reality is that any radical change, systemic, in insurance policies, and even methods of doing issues, can also be referred to as a revolution. In truth within the checklist of calls for introduced by Sowere’s group – International Coalition for Safety and Democracy – there was no suggestion of overthrowing the federal government. The group merely introduced a guidelines of extraordinarily idealistic calls for – abolishing tuition charges in Universities and schools, returning gasoline costs to what they have been earlier than 1999, enforcement of the brand new minimal wage of N30, 000 monthly throughout the nation – amongst others.

Electronic mail: [email protected]

Disclaimer: “The views/contents expressed on this article are the only real accountability of Prof. Jideofor Adobe and don’t essentially mirror these of The Nigerian Voice. The Nigerian Voice is not going to be accountable or answerable for any inaccurate or incorrect statements contained on this article.”

Supply hyperlink

About joseph